Price Guide - P

Loose Price MIB Price Pony Name Release Year Release Type

Store or Country Exclusive

Price Valid as of Date Price Ref
  $8-10 Paradise Island 2007 Best Friends    6/09 tp
$4-6   Paradise Palms 2005 Dream Design    3/09 tp
    Paradise Palms 2005 Limited Edition Numbered Ponies WorldinAdvance    
  $6-8 Party Cake 2007 Best Friends    6/10 tp
    Peach Blossom 2006 Crystal Design       
$3-4   Peach Surprise 2005 w/ Tea Lily Avon 9/09 arena
    Peach Surprise 2006 Set w/ Water Fountain JC Penney    
    Peach Surprise 2006 Sleepover Dreams Discount Chain    
    Peach Surprise 2008 Sleepover Dreams       
    Peachie Keen 2005 Single Discount Chain    
$3-6   Peachy Pie 2004 Dance Studio bonus Sparkle pony Walmart 3/09 tp
    Peachy Pie 2004 Limited Edition Numbered Ponies WorldinAdvance    
$4-6   Peachy Pie 2004 Sparkle    3/09 tp
  $8-12 Pearly Pie 2007 Pegasus    6/09 tp
$3-5 $4-8 Penny Candy 2005 Single Target 5/09
4/10

arena
arena

  $6-10 Pepperberry 2004 Special Release KB Toys 6/09 tp
$3-5   Periwinkle 2004 Celebration Salon Value Pack w/ Triple Treat, Periwinkle, Skywishes    6/09 tp
$3-5   Periwinkle 2004 Jewel    6/09 tp
$3-5   Periwinkle 2004 Sweet Reflections Dress Shop Sams Club 6/09 tp
$3-5   Petal Blossom 2004 Super Long Hair    5/09 arena
$3-5   Petal Blossom 2005 Picnic       
$3-5   Petal Blossom  2004 Super Long Hair w/ bonus Flower Flash       
$6-9   Petal Dove
(So-soft pony)
2004 "Baby Alive"   5/09 tp
    Petite Petunia 2006 Let's Go (Super Long Hair) International    
    Piccolo 2004 Build-a-pony Disney    
    Piccolo 2004 Limited Edition Numbered Ponies WorldinAdvance    
$3-4   Piccolo 2004 Perfectly    6/09 tp
    Piccolo 2005 Tea Time Fun Discount Chain    
    Pick-a-Lilly 2004 2-pack Dress Up w/ Sunny Salsa KB Toys    
$4-5   Pineapple Paradise 2004 Limited Edition Numbered Ponies WorldinAdvance 5/09 arena
$4-5   Pineapple Paradise 2005 Sunny Scents    5/09 arena
    Pink Petals 2007 Breezies Parade International    
$4-6   Pink Sunsparkle 2003 Celebration Castle    5/09 tp
    Pink Sunsparkle 2004 3-pack w/ Fluttershy, Toola Roola Target    
$4-6   Pink Sunsparkle 2004 Celebration Castle bonus Romperooni    5/09 tp
    Pink Sunsparkle 2008 3-pack w/ Fluttershy, Toola Roola       
$4-5   Pinkie Pie 2003 Glitter w/ charm    6/09 tp
    Pinkie Pie 2003 Glitter w/ charm and bonus Charming Bday Video       
    Pinkie Pie 2003 Limited Edition Numbered Ponies WorldinAdvance    
$180-220   Pinkie Pie (Licensing Show) 2003 Limited Release in bag Licensing Show 6/09 tp
$180-200   Pinkie Pie (Licensing Show) 2003 Limited Release in box    6/09 tp
    Pinkie Pie 2004 Disney Princess "Cinderella" Disney    
    Pinkie Pie 2005 Pinkie Pie bonus Bellaluna Discount Chain    
    Pinkie Pie II 2003 Glitter       
    Pinkie Pie II 2004 Perfect Hair Set Australia?    
    Pinkie Pie II 2005 Whimsical Winter       
    Pinkie Pie II 2007 Collector Edition Tin Australia    
    Pinkie Pie III 2004 Pie Party Fun       
    Pinkie Pie III 2005 Easter Egg       
    Pinkie Pie IV 2007 4-pack DVD set Australia    
    Pinkie Pie IV 2007 Sharing Tea w/ Minty MLP Live    
  $4-6 Pinkie Pie V
(3d symbol)
2007 Favorite Friends    3/10 arena
$30-35 $35-40 Pinkie Pie VI  2007 Limited Release MLP Fair 3/09 tp
    Pinkie Pie VI  2007 Pony Party Book/CD       
    Pinkie Pie VII 2007 Single w/ party hat       
    Pinkie Pie VII 2008 2-pack Dress up with Sweetie Belle Toys R Us    
    Pinkie Pie VII 2008 Bucket w/ Toola-Roola, Scootaloo Australia    
    Pinkie Pie VII 2008 Core Friends       
$5-7 $20-40 Pinkie Pie VII 2008 Inspirational Words Collector Set    11/09 arena
    Pinkie Pie VII 2008 Limited Release Toy Fair/Press Kit    
    Pinkie Pie VII 2008 Party Dress Up       
$4-5 $5-7 Pinkie Pie VII 2008 Single w/ Eyeshadow    5/09 arena
    Pinkie Pie VII 2008 Single w/ kite       
    Pinkie Pie VII 2008 Single w/ kite       
    Pinkie Pie VII 2008 Single w/ name on leg       
    Pinkie Pie VII 2008 Single w/ name on leg and bonus DVD       
    Pinkie Pie VII 2008 Special Day DVD       
    Pinkie Pie VII 2008 Valentine       
    Pinkie Pie VII 2009 Easter Egg       
    Pinkie Pie VII 2009 Single Discount Chain    
    Pinkie Pie VII 2009 Valentine       
    Pinkie Pie VIII 2008 Winter       
$40-70 $50-75 Pony Project (Black) 2005 Limited Release NYC Pony Project Art Show 4/09
9/09
tp
tp
  $75-125 Pony Project (TAF Symbols) 2005 Limited Release NYC Pony Project Art Show - VIP Only 9/09 tp
$17-25 $20-40 Pony Project (White) 2005 Limited Release SDCC 9/09 tp
$12-15 $20 Port-o-bella 2004 w/ Lickety-Split Kmart 6/09
3/09
tp
tp
    Precious Gem 2006 Fancy Hair Pony       
    Precious Gem 2006 Fancy Hair Pony w/ bonus Rose Garden International    
  $15-18 Precious Gem 2006 Fancy Hair Pony Bonus Pack w/ Secret Wish   5/09 tp
$20-30   Pretty Palace 2006 Crystal Rainbow Castle Bonus Walmart 5/09 arena
$5   Pretty Parasol 2006 Carriage Pony    9/09 arena
    Pretty Pop 2007 Best Friends       
$4-6   Princess Peppermint 2004 4-pack Toys R Us 6/09 tp
$5-7
with
access
  Pumpkin Tart 2006 Halloween Target 6/09 tp
    Purple Petunia 2007 Breezies Parade International    
$3-6 $18-24 Puzzlemint 2006 Grand Puzzleventure Game    9/09
6/09
tp
tp

NOTE : The Price Reference column refers to where the estimated value came from.

tp = My Little Pony Trading Post
arena = My Little Pony Arena
ebay = Ebay :)